Skip to Content

The Real Cause of Arguments

Apr 21, 2011

Spiritual Insight from Eckhart Tolle's Stillness Speaks

Eckhart Tolle asks whether we experience frequent, repetitive drama in our close relationships.

The simple fact is, he says, in many of our lives “relatively insignificant disagreements often trigger violent arguments and emotional pain.”

What’s really going on when disagreements escalate into arguments and people end up getting their feelings hurt?

Eckhart explains:

At the root of such experiences lie the basic egoic patterns: the need to be right and, of course, for someone else to be wrong, that is to say, identification with mental positions.

Why do so many of us have such a need to be right over minor issues that ultimately matter not a hill of beans?

It comes from our insecurity.

When our identity is that of our ego, instead of grounded in our essential being, we feel we have to “prove” something in order to feel okay about ourselves. And so we take up positions and argue our point.

Do you sometimes catch yourself taking a position over something you know deep down you really don’t know for sure, insisting you are correct when you suspect you might not be right at all?

Or perhaps you assert something to be true when you don’t actually believe it yourself? But you said it, and now you’re sticking to it.

Eckhart continues:

There is also the ego’s need to be periodically in conflict with something or someone in order to strengthen its sense of separation between “me” and the “other” without which it cannot survive.

The ego is tricky, luring us into debate, argument, disagreement, even to the point of fighting or falling out.

When we are centered in our essence, we have no need of an identity, in fact no need of the ego at all. We have nothing to prove to either ourselves or anyone else. We flow in life, without thinking about "who I am" and trying to be that person.

 

*Editor's note: The Compassionate Eye appears Monday through Friday. Eckhart Tolle's second book, Stillness Speaks, which followed The Power of Now and preceded A New Earth, is available in hardback and also on CD. To go more deeply into living in the present moment in an ongoing state of consciousness, especially as it relates to being true to ourselves in our relationships with others, join us in the daily blog Consciousness Rising.

tamyt143's picture

I agree with most of the above statements regarding the ego and how it can lead you astray by creating unnecessary drama in our lives and relationships. Looking back on my life I can remember many rediculous arguments that became full fledged wars out of something trivial. However, I'm also a bit confused. What happens when someone you trusted and loved dearly betrays that trust with years of lies and deceipt? You say its the ego that makes up stories and causes conflict but isnt it actually the other persons deception that has caused the conflict? How do you deal with these people and not haev an underlying judgement toward that person based on the facts of their past behavior? To forgive someone is one thing but to say that my ego is responsible for my inner turmoil and my inability to see beyond anothers egoic behavior is something I just do not understand. There are truly times when the facts about someone are legitimate and not created by someones out of control thoughts. How do you deal with situations like this without losing yourself ?

David Robert Ord's picture

Thanks for an excellent question. I have addressed some of it in today's Compassionate Eye, Tuesday June 14. I also recommend Dr David Schnarch's latest book Intimacy & Desire, which is an amazing treatise on how the difficulties in relationships can enable us to grow. If you have further questions, I'll be glad to address them.

Kate123's picture

I am really beginning to practice with my eyes wide open how the ego feeds off from the 5 senses. The emotional patterns that the ego is used to by the time we are adults requires certain sense-fodder. When I on purpose choose to "fast" from giving my focus to what another's outer appearance or behavior is tempting me to read into it, I am finding the ego has no food to keep up it's desire to go into familiar emotional tailspins. The ego needs to make up stories and have us eat them in order to live through our bodies. When I choose to switch off what the ego radio station is blaring, I find my Oneness with the Present...that stillness that contains the grace that supplies me with all I need in the here and now.